This is hysterical to me:
Seriously. You either are. Or, you aren't. If you need to consult a blog poll to see what the preppiest casual shoe is, you don't need to be wearing them. It's either your look, or it isn't. If it isn't...don't try it. Seriously. It won't fit.
P.S. My computer is STILL screwed up and I'm getting grumpy. Can you tell :)